The Sugar Cream Pie is the Indiana State Pie, and we love to represent it with our own recipe that has been in our family for generations! Our Sugar Cream Pie begins with a pre-baked flaky homemade pie crust loaded to the brim with our secret recipe- a warm, fresh, creamy, buttery filling. Each pie is sprinkled lightly with a dusting of cinnamon.

9-inch | Serves 8 people

*This pie comes frozen- ready to thaw, slice and enjoy! Share a taste of Indiana with your guests! Enjoy our flavorful pies, made without added preservatives or fillers.