skip to Main Content
(219) 261-2138 (Remington) | (765) 838-1590 (West Lafayette) info@homesteadbuttery.com

WHAT'S IN OUR FREEZER?

We know you’re busy- that’s why we exist. Allow us to simplify your mealtime with the convenience of our frozen ‘take & bake’ casseroles (including breakfast casseroles!), chicken pot pies, quiche, calzones, frozen ready-made soups, danish, scones, cookies, unbaked frozen pies, cake rolls, and more! These flavorful homemade products are the perfect solution to your busy schedule! We take great pride in knowing that our customers serve their families the best of the best when they put dinner on the table. Our products are not stuffed with added preservatives or fillers, but are made the old-fashioned way- just like home! 

PRINT OUR COMPLETE LIST HERE:

FROZEN CASSEROLES IN STOCK - THAW & BAKE!

HAVE QUESTIONS? SCROLL DOWN TO SEE ANSWERS BELOW.

Baked Chicken Alfredo Casserole

A creamy blend of penne pasta, Alfredo sauce & chicken, topped with grated parmesan cheese. (2 lb)

Chicken Pot Pie

Our Chicken Pot Pie is hands-down a customer favorite! The creamy filling is chock full of chicken and mixed veggies! Even better… it’s mounded in a flaky homemade pie crust and fluted beautifully around the edge. Sm 6 in. (serves 2-3) Lg 9 in. (serves 8)

Country Sausage Gravy

Our homemade country sausage gravy is the best! Creamy, and seasoned just right, just thaw, heat, and serve over your favorite fresh-baked fluffy biscuits! Breakfast-made-easy! (2 lb)

Farm-Fresh Spinach Bacon Quiche

A breakfast egg quiche loaded with a blend of spinach, Monterey Jack cheese, and Cheddar cheese… in a tender 6″ or 9″ homemade pie crust. Small (serves 2-3), Large (serves 8)

Luscious Lasagna Roll-Up Casserole

Lasagna noodles rolled up with a cheesy seasoned blend and a beefy spaghetti sauce over the top. Sprinkled with mozzarella/ provolone blend. Amazing! (2 lb)

Baked Spaghetti Casserole

Ground beef, our special recipe spaghetti sauce, noodles & cheese tossed together to create this delicious favorite! (2 lb)

Chicken & Rice Casserole

One of our very top sellers! Chicken and rice in a delicious creamy blend of mushrooms, cheese, and seasonings, and topped with French-fried onions. Ultimate comfort food. (2 lb)

Chicken Tetrazzini Casserole

Diced chicken in a saucy blend with spaghetti noodles and water chestnuts and sprinkled with parmesan cheese over the top. (2 lb)

Creamy Beef Stroganoff Casserole

Homestyle casserole with ground beef & Amish noodles in the traditional rick & cheesy sour cream stroganoff blend. Customer favorite! (2 lb)

Homestead Bacon Brunch Casserole

This hearty casserole has a little bit of everything to complete your morning breakfast! Includes shredded hash browns, eggs, bacon & cheddar cheese. (2 lb)

Cheesy Hashbrown Casserole

Everyone’s favorite! Shredded hash browns in a rich, buttery, cheesy blend… it goes great with any meat dish. (2 lb)

Homestead Breakfast Casserole

Country sausage stuffed in a delightful egg and cheese mixture. (2 lb)

Pigtails & Cheese Casserole

Vegetarian

OK, we really love the name of this all-American favorite ‘mac & cheese’ dish! Our secret cheese sauce recipe smothers curly cavatappi pasta and is then topped with buttered crushed cracker crumbs and light seasoning. Mmm! Kids (or kids-at-heart) of all ages will love this! (2 lb)

Reuben Bake Casserole

Our amazing recipe for a Reuben casserole that tastes just like our #1 customer favorite sandwich- the Reuben! Creamy, delightfully tangy, and topped with a crunchy buttered rye crumb topping! Warning! One serving may not be enough! (2 lb)

Shepherd's Pie Casserole

Comfort food! A fluffy mound of our homemade mashed redskin potatoes sit on top of a creamy ground beef & veggie blend, layered with cheddar cheese, French-fried onions, and real browned butter drizzled over the top. (2 lb)

Chicken & Broccoli Casserole

Jody’s personal favorite! A cheesy blend of diced chicken, broccoli, and rice, topped with French-fried onions. (2 lb)

Chicken Enchiladas Casserole

This dish satisfies with its Southwestern flair. Chicken, green chilies, sour cream, and cheese all layered between soft taco shells, then covered in enchilada sauce. Yummy! (2 lb)

Cinnamon French Toast Casserole

This sweet and comforting breakfast dish is perfect to get your day started! The cinnamon streusel topping adds just the right touch! Bake and serve with your favorite pancake syrup. (2 lb)

Holiday Dressing

October-December

A traditional family recipe passed down from generation to generation. We don’t use giblets in this recipe, but rather diced chicken. All made from scratch and so delicious! (2 lb)

Prized Swiss Ham Bake Casserole

Fresh-from-the-farm flavor with its comforting blend of melted Swiss cheese, off-the-bone ham & noodles tossed together. Topped with buttered cracker crumbs. (2 lb)

Calzone

The taste of pizza wrapped up in a warm pizza crust! Salami, ham, sauce, and ooey gooey cheese. A much heartier and yummier option than any frozen pizza you can pick up from the store! Serves 6-8.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

ABOUT OUR CASSEROLES, QUICHES, & POT PIES

How do I bake the casseroles from a frozen state?

We recommend that you put the casserole in your fridge overnight to thaw it, and then follow the baking instructions on the label. The casseroles take approximately 30-45 minutes to bake. The quiche and pot pie take longer.

What if I don't have time to thaw it overnight?

No worries! Our foil pans are microwave-safe, as long as they do not touch the microwave wall. Remove the casserole lid before microwaving the frozen casserole until defrosted. After it is defrosted, proceed with usual instructions. It may also be baked from the frozen point, but will require a little more time.

How many people do your casseroles serve?

Our casseroles serve 3-5 people.

How many people do your pot pies, quiche, and braids serve?

Our mini pot pie and quiche are the cutest little things! You can easily get two nice servings from this size. Our 9″ pot pie & quiche serves 8. Our braid and calzone serves approximately 8.

How long will your frozen products keep in the freezer?

Our frozen products can easily and safely be stored in the freezer for up to 4-6 months (or longer) from the time of the purchase, however, for optimum quality, we recommend using up within 4-5 weeks from the time of purchase.

Do you use additives or soy fillers in your products?

We make our products from scratch using wholesome ingredients. We do not use fillers, additives, or preservatives.

VIEW OUR GALLERY

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: API requests are being delayed for this account. New posts will not be retrieved.

There may be an issue with the Instagram access token that you are using. Your server might also be unable to connect to Instagram at this time.

Mission Statement

The Homestead is committed to simplifying and enhancing our customers' lives through convenience, quality, and flavor of our products. We claim the opportunity to provide a welcoming and homey atmosphere to all who enter the threshold of our door.

We cannot guarantee that any of our products are free from allergens (including dairy, eggs, soy, tree nuts, wheat, and others) as we use shared equipment to prepare, store and serve. Thank you.

Testimonials

"Today was my first time stopping at the Lafayette location and it was wonderful. Staff was great and took care of my needs with true smiles on their faces. That means so much when stopping anywhere for the first time. I love the frosted sugar cookies I took home and a delicious Reuben sandwich!"  -JQ

"Cute and clean. Good food and nice selection of baking goods: spices, yeasts, decorations." -MK

Locations

36 S. Ohio St. Remington, Indiana 47977

1550 Win Hentschel Blvd, West Lafayette, IN 47906

Follow Us

Employment Application

Donation Request Form

Copyright 2021- All Rights Reserved

Back To Top